Recently, I interviewed Jordan, who was recently diagnosed with Graves’ disease. In this episode she opens up about managing symptoms like heart palpitations, bloating, and fatigue while following the AIP diet and taking calming herbs, iodine, and other targeted supplements. If you would prefer to listen to the interview you can access it by Clicking Here.
Dr. Eric Osansky:
Welcome to another Save My Thyroid health audit. I am chatting here with Jordan, who was diagnosed with Graves’. Thank you so much for joining us, Jordan.
Jordan:
Absolutely. Thank you for having me.
Dr. Eric:
Really looking forward to this conversation. You were diagnosed with Graves’ not too long ago. You put two weeks when you filled out the application for this audit. That was a few weeks ago, so I guess it’s been a little over a month since you were diagnosed now?
Jordan:
Yes.
Dr. Eric:
Any family history that you know of with Graves’ or any other thyroid or autoimmune thyroid conditions?
Jordan:
Yes. My mom was diagnosed with Graves’. My grandmother on her side had hypothyroidism, but I’m not sure if it was related to Hashimoto’s. There are definitely thyroid issues in my family.
Dr. Eric:
Just out of curiosity, how did you learn about me?
Jordan:
When I was first diagnosed, I knew right away that I wanted to do my best to reverse this naturally. I didn’t want to go on medication. My husband is a big podcast listener. We both went right at it, trying to research different methods to heal myself naturally. He actually came across your podcast, and we listened to it together, which started my journey.
Dr. Eric:
You said you read my book. You must have gone through them pretty quickly since you were just diagnosed. Did you listen to the audio versions?
Jordan:
I read them. I get pretty focused when I’m researching. I spent day in, day out researching how to heal. I read all the books I could as fast as I could to start right away.
Dr. Eric:
Wonderful. What you put down here on the application is you were actually being treated for a concussion. Then you were tested for TSH during a routine visit. You asked for the test because it wasn’t tested for over a year. The primary care doctor found it was low. You saw an endocrinologist, who did the diagnosis for Graves’. You started working with a naturopath, taking some supplements. Are you still following AIP?
Jordan:
I am. This will be my sixth week, I believe.
Dr. Eric:
As far as some of your challenges here, exercise due to heart symptoms. I don’t know if you’re still having bloating and stomachaches with AIP. You listed that as well as the supplements you’re taking. Are you still experiencing those same symptoms with AIP?
Jordan:
Yes, I am. I feel like it’s improved. I’ve gotten used to it. I still get stomachaches after my meals. My heart-related issues are the same. I am still getting palpitations pretty frequently. Getting heart rate spikes when exercising. They have improved since I started with AIP and some supplements, but they’re still there.
Dr. Eric:
Were you experiencing any digestive symptoms prior to following AIP?
Jordan:
I was. I have pretty much my entire life been living with bloating and stomachaches after every meal. I have eaten a very whole, organic diet before I was diagnosed. Didn’t really matter what I was eating. I was always bloated.
Dr. Eric:
Okay. Did the naturopath you are working with do any gut-related testing?
Jordan:
No. I had asked about that. He mentioned he doesn’t do any testing. He did an intake meeting, where we went through my symptoms and the timeline. He was pretty confident I have SIBO. He says he doesn’t recommend or do any testing himself. He is confident in it, and he is treating me for that.
Dr. Eric:
Okay. You are taking an herbal approach?
Jordan:
Yes, I believe it’s an antifungal. I have a pretty long list of herbs I am taking for it.
Dr. Eric:
Just for the SIBO itself?
Jordan:
For the SIBO itself and other digestive aids.
Dr. Eric:
It sounds like it very well might be SIBO. The treatment typically is either an herbal antimicrobial, or there is antibiotics. It’s called Rifaximin. There is also the Elemental Diet, which is the liquid diet that most people don’t want to follow unless it is really bad. The herbs usually work well.
Have you noticed any positive changes? It sounds like it’s not as bad since you said you started AIP. I’m wondering if you think that’s at least in part due to taking the supplements.
Jordan:
I think it’s definitely been improving since my switch. I was eating a lot of grains prior and some gluten and dairy here and there. I do think it’s improved, but I can’t tell if it’s from AIP or the supplements that he is giving me.
Dr. Eric:
Okay. I try to be conservative with testing. In this case, usually I like to try to see if it’s SIBO or if there is something else going on. Since you already started on the protocol, it makes sense to follow it. If it is SIBO, that is a challenge. Most of the time, the herbs work. Sometimes, they don’t. If it doesn’t work, it would just be interesting to see what direction he goes in. Let’s hope it does knock out the symptoms.
If it knocks out the symptoms, then the thing with SIBO is sometimes it could come back. You might not have spoken about this yet, but there are prokinetics that some people need to take to help maintain the gut motility even after getting rid of SIBO.
The only way you know if you need those is to either go on them, and then eventually stop taking them, or some people don’t go on them at all and see if it comes back.
The first step is obviously seeing if the supplements help with the digestive symptoms, which seem to be related to SIBO. You will see how that goes.
The AIP diet, it’s not common for someone to have those symptoms. If someone has another condition, like if they have SIBO or a histamine intolerance, then some of those foods are high in histamine that are AIP-friendly. Some of the foods that are friendly are higher in FODMAPs and could also aggravate SIBO if someone is dealing with it.
The AIP diet usually won’t cause those symptoms, but it does sound like based on what you mentioned that eating those foods, if they cause those symptoms, which they did, a good chance it would be SIBO. Hopefully, those digestive symptoms subside, not only just improve, but completely go away.
You said he doesn’t do any testing? Or just in this case, he doesn’t do any testing.
Jordan:
He doesn’t do testing with any of his patients.
Dr. Eric:
Okay. Everybody is different. I’ve had people on the podcast like that. I have had people on the podcast where they do the complete opposite. They go crazy with testing and recommend 5-6 different tests, which gets expensive. I usually try to go in between. Start out conservatively, and hopefully we don’t need to get aggressive with people I work. Sometimes, we do. It all depends on the health history.
The next question I have for you is are you taking anything to lower the thyroid hormones, whether it’s antithyroid mediation or herbs such as bugleweed?
Jordan:
Yes. I have a thyroid calming supplement, which is a mix of motherwort, lemon balm, and bugleweed. He has me on an additional dosage of bugleweed as well. I do feel like those are helping.
Dr. Eric:
Do you have a scheduled thyroid panel as well to see what changes are taking place?
Jordan:
I do have it. The order is in. I am unsure when to test, especially since I just had influenza, and I feel that all of my symptoms came back as they were on day one. I’m unsure when to test.
Dr. Eric:
If someone is sick, usually I recommend waiting at least a week after you’re feeling better, to do the testing. In a bad case of influenza, you might want to wait a little bit longer because that could throw off the numbers. Sorry you dealt with that.
When I dealt with Graves’, I took bugleweed like you did. You are also taking the thyroid calming formula. Is that by Herb Pharm?
Jordan:
It’s a tincture.
Dr. Eric:
Is the company Herb Pharm? Do you know the company name? They have one called Thyroid Calming Formula.
Jordan:
It’s called ThyroCalm.
Dr. Eric:
Maybe it’s something different.
Jordan:
It’s called David Winston’s Thyroid Calmpound.
Dr. Eric:
I haven’t heard of that. That’s the one that has all three? Then you are taking bugleweed separately.
Jordan:
Yes.
Dr. Eric:
It sounds like it’s working. When I dealt with Graves’, I took bugleweed by itself, and I felt my symptoms, my heart rate was lowering, palpitations were improved. I still experienced some palpitations, so I added motherwort.
It sounds like you’re also noticing a difference when it comes to the symptoms. The only way to know for sure if it’s working is to do a blood test eventually. If you’re feeling the symptoms like I did, then it sounds like it’s helping, which is good. Some people need to take antithyroid medication, but when you can avoid it, that’s a good thing. Hopefully, you can continue to avoid it and have your symptoms managed by the herbs.
As far as exercise, with my patients, I usually recommend to take it easy, at least on the cardiovascular exercise. Try to do some light walking. Usually, I recommend resistance or weight bearing exercise because it’s common to lose muscle mass and bone density. You also want to listen to your body. Do you know what on average your resting heart rate is?
Jordan:
My resting is about 83, so it’s not too high resting. It’s the spikes. If I start stretching, it can go up to 170. Even just doing yoga, it could go to 190. I’ve gotten the full cardiology signoff that everything looked fine in terms of my heart health and structure. It gets very high very fast with little exertion.
Dr. Eric:
That is a pretty high spike. The resting heart rate is not too bad. It’s a little bit high. I’d be more nervous about it going up to 170 or 190. You said that is not just exercise. If you’re walking or cleaning the house, does it get up that high?
Jordan:
It does. It depends on the day. Some days, I feel great, and it’s more managed. The next day, I might just be going up the stairs, and it goes up to 170, 180. I’m pretty active, and I was prior. It’s a huge change for me. It’s hard to limit those activities.
Dr. Eric:
Was that the case even before you dealt with influenza?
Jordan:
Yes. I had three days before I had influenza where I had no palpitations, no spikes, and I felt great. Then I had influenza. They all came back. About every two minutes, I am having a palpitation. Getting up from the chair, I can feel my heart rate raise pretty quickly. That was similar to when I first was diagnosed.
Dr. Eric:
It sounds like things were heading in the right direction until you got the influenza. Then it went back to where it was.
Jordan:
Yes.
Dr. Eric:
Would you say you were 80%, 90% feeling better from influenza? Or not even that much better?
Jordan:
I would say I’m about 70% better. The fatigue is still there. I still have a cough. I haven’t had fever or body aches in a while. I can tell I’m on the up and up.
Dr. Eric:
That’s good. It sounds like that definitely set you back. As much as you might want to exercise, and I have been there, too, I am not going to say not to exercise, but listen to your body. Maybe for now, limit it to light exercise, light walking, light resistance exercise. 70% is better than 30%, but you might have at least a week or two, possibly longer, until you are feeling better as far as the influenza goes.
Once you get to that point, wait another week, and then do a blood test. If it seems like 2-3 weeks go by, and you are still dragging along, and you are not feeling 100% yet, at that point, you might want to do it anyway. I wouldn’t wait 3-4 months to do a thyroid panel. When was the last test you had done?
Jordan:
That was in December.
Dr. Eric:
It’s been about two months or so, depending on when in December you had it.
Jordan:
Yes.
Dr. Eric:
I would say to give it another few weeks. If you’re feeling at that point where you are feeling 100% or almost there, wait an extra week. If you’re still not feeling where you feel you need to be, you might want to do it anyway and see what the numbers are. Sometimes, with these viruses and other things, it can take a while.
I don’t know if I would wait four months to get a test. Hopefully, you don’t need to worry about it. In a week or two, you will make huge strides and feel significantly better with that.
As far as taking the right supplements because that was another thing you put down. I give some general recommendations. I give a probiotic; an omega-3 fatty acid, usually in the form of a fish oil; the bugleweed or motherwort or lemon balm, things like that based on the symptoms and the thyroid panel.
As far as other supplements, a lot of it does depend on the testing. For SIBO, it sounds like he recommended a lot of things. Usually for SIBO itself, I might recommend 3-4 things to help with getting rid of it. Maybe he has recommended other things to help with supporting the gut and gut repair, things like digestive enzymes, which I would understand. Are you taking any other supplements that are not related to SIBO?
Jordan:
Yes. I’m taking seeds or vitamins. Acetyl L-carnitine. He has me taking two a day. An activated B. My Vitamin D was very low on the last test, so he has me taking a 10,000 IU Vitamin D supplement each day. I have a K2 probiotic, glucose balance.
He is actually having me do pulsed iodine once a week. I know it’s opposite of what I would expect, just in researching and reading, but he has me taking two drops of iodine once a week to help with my thyroid to be able to regulate the iodine function.
Dr. Eric:
Okay. You know how much iodine two drops is?
Jordan:
Yes, I can check. I have it right here. It is the J. Crow Lugal’s Solution, 2%.
Dr. Eric:
Lugal’s Solution?
Jordan:
J. Crow Lugal’s Solution, 2%. It says 4% potassium iodide and 2% iodine. I have two drops.
Dr. Eric:
Okay. As far as making the conversion, I know tablet-wise, lugal tablet is 12.5mg. I forget how many drops they give that is equivalent to that. You’re probably still taking mg.
It’s controversial for sure. Some will recommend to completely avoid iodine with hyperthyroidism; others will recommend taking it. In some cases, iodine can lower thyroid hormone levels.
When I dealt with Graves’, this was over 15 years ago now, I was taught that you want to test for iodine and supplement for iodine if you’re deficient in iodine. I was more on the iodine bandwagon. Now, I’m not anti-iodine. I do recommend getting iodine from food if someone has a multivitamin. I’m not concerned about that. I’m more cautious about people supplementing separately with iodine. Depends on the situation. Are you taking any selenium along with that?
Jordan:
He has me taking three Brazil nuts a day. It goes against AIP, so I’m cheating a bit with that. He would rather have me take Brazil nuts than supplement with selenium, and I asked.
Dr. Eric:
I have a podcast episode that I chat about that. I like Brazil nuts. I eat Brazil nuts. On a wellness basis, it’s a good idea to try to rely as much as you can on food. The only downside is you have no idea how much selenium is in each Brazil nut. You could be getting a good amount, or you might be getting a lower amount, depending on how much selenium is in each Brazil nut. I usually recommend selenium supplementation while someone is healing, so we know how much is in there. I’m not saying you should do that.
What you’re taking sounds good. B complex. I usually like to see what someone’s adrenals look like before recommending a B complex. B vitamin is water soluble, so it won’t hurt necessarily to take it.
The L-carnitine, you are taking acetyl L-carnitine, which I don’t know if he recommended for the thyroid or other purposes.
Vitamin D, I can understand. It sounds like the K as well, the K2, to help guide the calcium into the bone. That makes sense.
The iodine, not everybody would agree with. I can’t say I currently take that approach. In the past, I would give separate supplementation. I also based it on urinary testing.
It’s all about progress. As long as you are progressing, that is what we want to see obviously. If your thyroid numbers improve, if you feel better, if your antibodies are heading in the right direction, that’s all great.
If not, then that’s where more detective work needs to be done to see if the SIBO has been eradicated. In his case, he will go more by symptoms than testing since he didn’t do the testing. He will have his own approach.
Does he do applied kinesiology, like muscle testing?
Jordan:
Not that he’s mentioned.
Dr. Eric:
He’s really going by symptoms and the blood test. He does pay attention to the blood test but not any muscle testing or functional medicine testing.
Jordan:
Correct.
Dr. Eric:
Okay. Every practitioner is different. You’re under his care. Just see how you’re improving. It’s not the approach I take, but just because I don’t take that approach, this doesn’t mean my approach is right and his is wrong. If you get really good results, that is what you’re hoping for, and that would be a good thing. If you get great results, you also did so without spending money on testing. Can’t complain about that.
I guess as far as the next step, you’re working with someone. I would continue following their recommendations for SIBO protocol. It sounds like what you’re doing with the herbs to manage symptoms is helping, but the only way to know is by doing another blood test in the future. I wouldn’t wait too long before doing that. A little bit of a catch-22 because you are getting over the influenza.
AIP diet, six weeks. It sounds like you’re doing a great job.
The one thing I will say about AIP and SIBO, everybody is different with their approach diet-wise. As you probably know, you read my books and listened to my podcast. I like AIP. Usually, if someone is healing from SIBO, a lot of times I will follow that low FODMAP diet, which I talk about in one of my books.
I also mention that I usually don’t combine diets. I don’t have someone do AIP and low FODMAP because it’s more difficult. If someone is following SIBO, we might prioritize low FODMAP while they are healing. Then make the switch to AIP.
Again, as long as you’re not struggling too much with the diet, as long as you are not finding it too restrictive, and it sounds like you’re maybe not completely avoiding high FODMAP foods, you are just dealing with bloating and gas, it sounds like it’s helping the SIBO protocol.
That is the approach I would sometimes take. Maybe have someone not do AIP right away if they are dealing with SIBO and follow low FODMAP instead. Then incorporate AIP later on.
If you are familiar with the 5R protocol, the very first R is Remove. That’s what you’re focusing on right now. Not to say you can’t focus on Replace, Reinoculate, Repair, Rebalance now. In the case of SIBO, sometimes you want to do that exclusively before incorporating some of the other components of the 5R protocol.
Before we wrap up, any last questions you have, Jordan?
Jordan:
No, I really appreciate your time, thank you.
Dr. Eric:
You’re welcome. Overall, it sounds like you’re doing a really good job. Keep up the good work. Hope you get some good results.
Thank you so much for listening to my podcast, reading my books, and agreeing to do this audit.
Jordan:
Absolutely, thank you.
Dr. Eric:
Take care.